Anna Miller has her whole life ahead of her and everything to look forward to this Christmas. She's always dreamed of being a wife and mother on an Amish farm, and her dreams are about to come true. She's certain that this Christmas, after three long years, Jed Graber is finally going to propose. When Jed asks her out on a special Christmas date, Anna knows the moment has come. But instead of proposing, Jed tells her he's moving hundreds of miles away, and Anna's world comes crashing down. Later, Jed's brother, Dale, tries to comfort her, but she draws away from everyone. During the ensuing year, Anna struggles to pick up the pieces of her life. When Christmas rolls around again, Anna faces the prospect of spending it alone once more. Unless she truly is seeing something special in the eyes of Dale. But after what Jed did to her, how can she really trust his brother?