Something between them happened. Something that should have never happened. But it did. The town of Bridgehaven is home to the shy and timid ELISHA ARMSTRONG. She has a crush on Christopher Sullivan, a baseball pitcher and popular student at Bridgehaven high school. It's not long before romance blossoms. That is until an old flame arrives and threatens to come in between Chris and Elisha. Unfortunately, that matter is only the beginning of the end. The moment Elisha notices an apparition of a familiar person following her, a chain of events unfolds in Bridgehaven. Terrible secrets and unforgiving liars are exposed. Trust and friendships are tested yet some are broken. Elisha finds herself in the middle of it all. From 'the casual girlfriend' to 'a lady of lies', she vows to find out the truth even if it kills her...again.