What if you fell in love with someone, but never met them? All you have are their handwritten letters that captured your heart. Welcome to Mark Dawson's world! After having to leave his dream job and the softball team he loves, Mark moves from Atlanta to the mountains of north Georgia to escape his past. When he visits a used bookstore and finds a letter in a copy of his favorite book, The Great Gatsby, he finds a kindred spirit. The only thing he knows about the woman is her name is Catherine, she lives in Manhattan, and has a broken heart. Since neither are on social media, the only thing they know about each other comes from their words written in letters by a fountain pen. Eventually, Mark's feelings get the better of him, and he searches for Catherine. But what will happen when they finally come face to face? Will their love be signed, sealed and delivered? Or will it be three strikes for love?