In 1931, the discovery of human remains packed into railway trunks sent shockwaves across the United States. The crime was horrifying. The response was swift. And the woman at the centre of it all, Winnie Ruth Judd, was sentenced to die. What followed was not justice as the public imagined it, but a long institutional reckoning. The Trunk Murders is a work of historical true crime that moves beyond lurid retellings to examine what happened after conviction: the death sentence the state could not carry out, the declaration of insanity that spared Judd's life, decades of psychiatric confinement, and the uneasy compromise of parole. Through court records, contemporary reporting, and institutional history, this book explores how the justice system manages cases it cannot resolve cleanly-where punishment, gender, mental health, and public fear collide. This is not a story of mystery. It is a story of consequences, containment, and the limits of justice itself.