On July 11, 1920, Mabel Kenyon of Pawcatuck, Connecticut shot and killed her lover. The child born of the secret union, baby Hugh, was left to be raised by a resentful husband after Mabel's incarceration. Neighbors regularly heard Hugh's painful screams echoing out from the Kenyon house. Nearly twenty years to the day of the murder, screams rang out over Connecticut again as Hugh bludgeoned his girlfriend in the dark, dense woods. Twenty-six years later, the decades-long rampage ended with a brutal mass murder in Albany, New York. The shocking saga of the Kenyon family had finally come to an end, leaving behind an incredible glimpse of the thin line between love and murder.