In Our Fantasy Island, amusement park ride tokens from a bygone summer hold the magic to transform the island the children see into a magical learning adventure. While the parents see the usual sights, the children bring "Old Barney" the Barnegat Lighthouse to life, eat pizza with Surf City's Tiki Surfers and ride a live Sea Dragon while learning about the navigational markers in the Barnegat Bay. The book doubles as a scrapbook and journal.