Heaven is a busy place, especially for social worker and angel-in-training Pixel Millet, who works in the Paradise City Department of Discipline. When he receives a red folder containing violations of The Cupid's Oath by unruly Cupid's assistant Cupid-1637, Pixel must advocate and defend him from being "flushed" to the lower regions. Pixel has one day to interview his client, review eight often funny and sometimes often funny and sometimes poignant romances mismanaged by Cupid-1637, and devise a defense to present before the administrative hearing. But, unfortunately for Pixel, he soon suspects someone higher up is rigging the outcome against them. And once he gets closer to the truth, it threatens to upset the foundations of heaven forever.